RSS

People just doing their jobs are not heroes, no matter how dangerous the work is

21 Apr

We have this asinine tendency to pedestalize those who we view as potentially or actually putting themselves in harm’s way for the rest of us.

We did it after 9/11, with all the hero worship of police and firefighters.

Now we’re doing it again, not just for those but for nurses, postal workers, grocery store workers, long haul truck drivers, etc.

I’d like to remind everyone: a hero is typically someone who has gone above and beyond the call of duty, and their pay grade, to act in some particularly selfless manner, possibly risking their own lives, to rescue or save someone else. The fictional truck driver in the Red Sovine song ‘Phantom 309’ who turned his wheels to avoid crashing into a school bus full of kids, to save their lives which cost him his own? If that had been a real person, we’d call him a hero, and rightly so; that kind of act is heroic.

Some regular truck driver who is delivering goods from coast to coast, ensuring we get fed, and our washing machines and couches and DVDs, whatever?

We are grateful to him, but just because he ostensibly faces more risk than us from this pandemic (whose threat has been in fact greatly exaggerated; it’s just a bad flu, not a bubonic plague), doesn’t make him a hero.

He’s just an ordinary joe doing his ordinary job.

God bless him, we thank him for his service, but no hero he.

Ditto grocery store workers, nurses, etc.

We seem to want to ‘democratize’ heroism, to make ordinary people into heroes.

They aren’t, except perhaps – hopefully – in the eyes of family, friends, loved ones.

But heroes are usually extraordinary people, even if they were ordinary people until they did some extraordinary and heroic deed.

That makes them extraordinary, when they go above and beyond what is expected of them and potentially or actually self-sacrificially putting one’s own health or life at risk, if need be.

Stop heroizing non-heroes.

 
25 Comments

Posted by on April 21, 2020 in Uncategorized

 

25 responses to “People just doing their jobs are not heroes, no matter how dangerous the work is

  1. Will S.

    April 21, 2020 at 11:10 pm

    If you are paid to do something dangerous, like go into burning buildings, esp. with protective equipment etc., you aren’t a hero for doing it. You receive danger pay maybe, but it’s still just your job…

    Someone who isn’t paid to go into a burning building, but does so anyway to rescue someone and save a life, even if they risk their own life and especially if they suffer or die because of it, is heroic. (Especially if no firefighters were around to rescue the other person; if they were, then he would just be a fool, possibly with a martyr complex…)

     
  2. electricangel

    April 21, 2020 at 11:13 pm

    “But heroes are usually extraordinary people, even if they were ordinary people until they did some extraordinary and heroic deed.

    That makes them extraordinary, when they go above and beyond what is expected of them and potentially or actually self-sacrificially, if need be.”

    Well, no. A hero doesn’t self-sacrifice. He goes into battle against enormous odds and by strength of character or muscle, overcomes them. The sacrifice comes in willingly facing a danger that’s likely to kill him, and yet he takes it on. In the end, however, there is no self-sacrifice.

    Christ on Easter becomes a hero: he overcomes death, and his victory isn’t just for himself but for all. By contrast, the firemen on 9/11 were almost all not heroes: they did not overcome, though they did charge up the steps heroically, knowing they were facing monstrous odds. You might call them tragic heroes, then. Had they actually put the fires out and saved people, heroes, conquering the flames for themselves and society.

     
    • Will S.

      April 21, 2020 at 11:16 pm

      Agreed, I didn’t mean those who willingly seek to die, but who are unafraid to face danger. I mean act self-sacrificially if need be, not seeking it out.

      Exactly. Christ is the ultimate hero, because He didn’t have any sins to die for; He died for the sins of others, all of God’s people.

       
    • Will S.

      April 21, 2020 at 11:18 pm

      I guess this is a matter of meaning of words here; if you do something that takes your life, you have sacrificed your life, even if you didn’t intend to. Therefore, I don’t think the term ‘acted self-sacrificially’ is incorrect, even if you didn’t intend to sacrifice yourself, you did.

       
    • Will S.

      April 21, 2020 at 11:20 pm

      But I could tweak that language…

       
    • Will S.

      April 21, 2020 at 11:23 pm

      I have clarified my meaning…

       
  3. feeriker

    April 22, 2020 at 12:47 am

    “If everyone is a hero, then no one is a hero.”

    It’s that simple.

     
    • Will S.

      April 22, 2020 at 1:14 am

      Exactly.

      In a way, this democratization of heros through hero-worship ordinary folks reflects either a jealousy of normals towards the real heroes, thus seeking to pull them down by elevating normals; and/or a feeling of inferiority towards true heroes, which is compensated for by again pulling them down by elevating normals.

       
      • info

        April 22, 2020 at 1:25 am

        Heroes. Unless one is Alexander the Great or Julius Caesar. One has no right actually to call oneself that.

        One must win against overwhelming odds. Like 300 vs Persian Army or if one is surrounded yet wins anyway.

         
      • Will S.

        April 22, 2020 at 2:33 am

        Indeed.

         
      • electricangel

        April 22, 2020 at 7:51 am

        What overwhelming odds did Caesar face? Alexander, yes. Caesar spent all his time marching through the countryside of Barbarians with lesser technology, akin to Europeans conquering Africans with machine guns against spears.

        Alexander defeated an equally-matched foe.

         
      • info

        April 22, 2020 at 9:46 pm

        @electricangel

        You may be right. Although they did have serious odds of losing at the Battle of Alesia if not for Julius Caesar.

        @Will S. @Electricangel
        Here is one example of a true hero you never knew before:

         
    • electricangel

      April 22, 2020 at 7:53 am

      Worse. By destroying the idea of heroism, they make it so no one takes up the challenge against long odds. Taleb talks about entrepreneurs being heroes, and given the odds against them if they fail, I’d have to agree.

      The powers that be want no challengers and no heroes, economic or martial. What they’ll get is a feeble and stagnant population and economy that is easy prey for a heroic society.

       
      • bluecat57

        April 22, 2020 at 9:42 am

        Entrepreneurs are NOT heroes. They are “just doing their job”. They have a dream for THEMSELVES which they desire to accomplish and profit from. They are NOT doing it primarily for others.

         
    • bluecat57

      April 22, 2020 at 9:39 am

      GMTA – Please (An overused word, but appropriate here since you will have to make an effort to find and read my comment. You don’t need to say “please” if you are asking someone to just do their job.) see my full comment.

       
  4. bluecat57

    April 22, 2020 at 9:44 am

    When everyone is a hero, no one is.
    Olde Wisdom from Thee Frugal Curmudgeon

    I’ve been saying that for decades. And I’ve been saying the same thing as Will S. is as well.
    Just doing your job does NOT make you a hero.

    Am I a hero if I lie to keep my family happy? All the world will see is a happy family. Isn’t that a parent’s job? Isn’t doing whatever is necessary to accomplish it heroic? NOT in this case, nor in the following one.

    Am I a hero if I follow an unlawful order? No, but the world is calling such law enforcement officers heroes for staying on the job.

    Let’s save the word HERO for the truly heroic and use some adjectives (OK English teachers you MAY correct me.) like:
    Courageous
    Dedicated
    Selfless
    Caring

    Please add your own and don’t just thank someone for doing their job (like wearing a uniform) but thank them for the SPECIFIC act that they have done for YOU PERSONALLY.

    PS – Pretty much every job is thankless. Remember that and just look the person serving you in the eye and smile. THAT will go a long way to making them feel like heroically showing up to work every day makes a difference.

     
  5. bluecat57

    April 22, 2020 at 9:48 am

    @info @electricangel – Let’s debate whether Alexander the Great or Julius Caesar were heroes. They may have done INDIVIDUAL heroic acts, which would make them heroes in THAT instance, but overall they were seeking power and prestige for THEMSELVES, not for others.

    Debate, please.

     
    • info

      April 23, 2020 at 3:17 am

      Far rarer in that case. But the kind of feats required for heroism is those kinds of acts.

       
  6. feeriker

    April 22, 2020 at 12:24 pm

    HERO = “Hyper-Exultation of the Really Ordinary”

     
  7. Dividualist

    April 22, 2020 at 1:13 pm

    Dear Patriactioanry,

    I haven’t commented on your blog before for the simple reason that I mostly agree with what you say. Not in this case. When you sign up for a job, you do so because you watched those people and talked with those people and you get a general idea how hard that job is. That is what you take into consideration when accepting the salary offer. For this pay, I am gonna do what these guys generally did in the last few years.

    And then a black swan like 9/11 or Corona happens and you live up to it and give your best, despite all the odds. That makes you a hero.

    Because NOBODY considers the theoretical maximum of challenge, difficulty or danger when signing up for a job. They consider the average level of that in the last few years. They do so not because not being unimaginative, but because their pay and other compensation actually depends on the average level of that in the last few years. And because that is what the guy hiring them tells them when they ask him just how hard it is going to be. Well in the last few years we had X fires or Y virus outbreaks and usually for the average employee that meant this or that.

    It seems to me you are applying the logic of soldiers for other jobs as well. Which is wrong. In the last few years the average soldier might not have fought. But he keeps continuously training for that. His superiors tell him, WW3 may break out, and we are training you for that. Nobody tells doctors and firefighters that we are training you for a major disaster. What they are told is really yeah we on the averare this level of fire cases or that level of virus cases, we handle it like this or that, on the average, that means you lose this or that amount of sleep a year, and that’s it.

     
    • Will S.

      April 22, 2020 at 11:26 pm

      Hi Dividualist, thanks for commenting. 🙂

      It’s true, certainly, that now job definitions have ostensibly changed (again, if one buys the establishment-promoted narrative that we have a genuine pandemic here that’s truly far worse than the flu, which I don’t hold to, but setting that aside), then it becomes more courageous for someone to take such risks.

      And again, I am grateful that people are doing jobs that ostensibly are more dangerous now than before.

      But the tautology remains, people who are paid to do dangerous work, are paid to do dangerous work.

      That’s commendable, but it is what they are supposed to be doing, based on the fact they are paid to do so, even if at some times more than others the risks are elevated.

      I want to commend people for doing dangerous work without calling them ‘heroes’, because it cheapens the meaning of the term ‘hero’, which used to be set aside for extraordinary deeds, not routine ones for which they are paid.

      Not intending to detract from people doing dangerous things, but also not wanting to diminish those who do even more than that, who go above and beyond.

      That’s all.

      Cheers. 🙂

       
  8. Will S.

    April 26, 2020 at 7:30 pm

    Oh, and BTW commercial pilots successfully landing planes ARE NOT FUCKING HEROES EITHER

    https://twitter.com/KillToParty/status/1254064090181365761

    IT’S THEIR FUCKING JOB

     
  9. Will S.

    April 26, 2020 at 7:34 pm

    https://twitter.com/RPK_/status/1254071592767959041

    That’s a Third World, esp. African, thing that has sadly caught on now in the West…

    Of course, this trend correlates with increased social and political power of minorities and hugely increased numbers of non-Western Third World immigrants, so it stands to reason perfectly, alas…

     

Leave a comment