Why George Floyd Died

04 Aug

Dreher actually gets it, mostly.

Here is the police body cam footage of the Minneapolis police officers’ encounter with George Floyd


Early, one of the officers has a gun on him, and tells him repeatedly to put his hands on the wheel. Floyd says, “I got shot the same way before.” Well then, says the cop, put your hands on the wheel when I tell you to.

The police tell him repeatedly to get out of the car, but he keeps saying, “Please don’t shoot me, please don’t shoot me.” Yet he refuses to obey them. At the 1:28 moment, Floyd says, “I just lost my mom, man.” (He was lying about that.)

At the 1:51 point, a female voice is heard saying, “Stop resisting!”

Floyd continues to resist arrest as they’re trying to cuff him. At about the 2:12 point, the officer says again, “Stop resisting!”

At 2:19, the police finally get the cuffs on Floyd, and put him back into the seat of his car.

In the seconds before a break at 3:57, one of the bystanders (a black woman) tells an officer that Floyd has mental problems. Then, at 3:57, we see Floyd cuffed and standing on the street. An officer says, “Are you on something right now?”

“No, nothing,” says Floyd.

This too was a lie. In fact, the autopsy revealed that Floyd had fentanyl and methamphetamine in his system at the time of his death. The autopsy also found that Floyd, 46, had “severe” heart disease, and that he died of a heart attack. The autopsy ruled that the fentanyl (“fentanyl intoxication”) and the meth might have contributed to his fatal heart attack. The autopsy also called his death a “homicide.”

At 4:38, one of the officers has Floyd against the police SUV, and tells him, “Stop falling down. Stay on your feet and face the car door.” Floyd is not complying with their orders. “Please, I want to talk with you man,” he shrieks at the police.

At 5:26, Floyd tells the police officers that he is “claustrophobic” — this, to say that he does not want to get into the police SUV. Remember that the supposedly claustrophic Floyd had been pulled out from behind the wheel of his own car. This claustrophobic man is not so afraid of confined spaces that he can’t stand being in a car. A reasonable person, by this point, might conclude that the clearly agitated Floyd is just talking trash to keep the cops from arresting him. He has been talking almost non-stop since the police first approached him, trying to convince the police to let him go.

At 5:38, Floyd denies for a second time that he is on drugs.

What’s striking too at this point is how polite and non-confrontational the police have been. They ask him repeatedly to get into the SUV.

“I’m gonna go in!” says Floyd, at 6:18.

“No, you’re not!” one of the cops replies — meaning in context, you’re saying you’re going to do this thing, but you are in fact refusing to do it.

They order him four or five more times to get into the SUV. He keeps refusing. He claims that he is afraid, that he’s claustrophobic, that he won’t be able to breathe. Voices of bystanders tell him to do what the cops tell him to do, to quit trying to “win.” Floyd says he’s “not trying to win.”

And then several more times, they order him to get in the car. One officer goes around to the other side, to try to pull Floyd in. Floyd offers to get into the front seat. No, an officer says. Floyd keeps resisting. At 7:48, he’s still resisting and shrieking, and the frustrated voice of an officer says, “Take a seat!”

Around 8:12, they finally put Floyd on the ground. He is continuing to protest, “I can’t breathe!”

That’s the end of the above video. We know what happened next.

That bodycam footage dramatically changes what we thought we knew about this story.

George Floyd did not just resist arrest. He spent at least eight minutes gasping and shrieking and carrying on like a lunatic, all the while refusing frequent, entirely legitimate orders by police. I had been under the impression that they had brutalized him from the beginning, throwing Floyd to the ground and kneeing him in the neck. That’s not remotely what happened. What happened is that these police officers gave Floyd chance after chance to obey. He was high on fentanyl and meth, though he denied twice that he was on anything, but his behavior was completely bizarre. Was it because he was high? Maybe. It might also be because he had four previous criminal convictions, and had done a prison stint for assault and robbery. What brought the cops in Minneapolis out that afternoon was that he was attempting to pass counterfeit bills in a local store. Floyd must have known that given his criminal record, he was going to be in a world of trouble over the fake currency.

The knee-in-the-neck procedure was only deployed by a cop after Floyd’s repeated refusal to comply with police orders simply to get into the police car. One can certainly argue about whether or not the neck restraint is wise and proper, but one cannot argue with the fact that it was permitted under Minneapolis police procedure:


The new bodycam video shows that Floyd had been actively resisting arrest for at least eight minutes! If George Floyd at any point in that eight minutes had simply obeyed the police’s lawful, legitimate orders, he would be alive today. After watching that video, it is easy to see why Officer Derek Chauvin applied the neck restraint to him. And it is easy to understand why Chauvin believed Floyd was lying when he said, “I can’t breathe” — Floyd had been standing on the street yelling over and over that he couldn’t breathe as a way to convince the officers not to make him get into the back of the car.

Those cops have been overcharged for political reasons, and are going to walk free.


When these police officers go free — as they will deserve to, based on what is seen on these cameras — riots are going to sweep the nation. As Whitlock says, sports stars, the media, and many others have promulgated a sacred narrative in which Floyd was the innocent victim of racist police officers. It is not true. I think a decent case could be made that Derek Chauvin used excessive force, even though the neck restraint was legal under Minneapolis police guidelines. But murder? Not remotely. You’re not going to get a conviction for that.

George Floyd is dead today almost entirely because of George Floyd. Watch that bodycam video above (it ends just as he is on the ground with Chauvin’s knee in his neck), and tell me how there is any other reasonable conclusion? All he had to do was obey the police, who gave him chance after chance after chance. They did not come down on him hard, with the neck restraint, because he was black. They came down on him because he hysterically resisted arrest, for at least eight minutes.

The media’s narrative is false. All the George Floyd riots, all the George Floyd protests, have been based on a lie. That lie, though, has become so fundamental to the left’s narrative that disbelieving it will be impossible for countless people.

Watch the video.


24 responses to “Why George Floyd Died

  1. silentmick1

    August 4, 2020 at 9:28 pm

    As is the case in virtually every one of these sorts of incidents the initial reporting and reaction are pure fiction and emotive reflex followed by days or weeks of ever more false analysis and condemnation followed, usually rather quietly, by the full story coming out and the truth of the situation begins to dawn. I do not believe the cops involved can get a fair trial anywhere in this country at this point but if they do there is every likelihood of acquittal or, at the very least, conviction on procedural errors and a minor sentence. This would be followed, of course, by rioting in several major cities though at this point there may not be much left to burn or loot. Hard times in the hood.

  2. fuzziewuzziebear

    August 4, 2020 at 11:24 pm

    There is a technique that rapists use to defend themselves when caught. It’s called DARVO, Deny, Accuse, and Reverse Victim Order. Cops have taken to it like ducks to water.
    What happened to George Floyd was unequivocally murder. It was with malice of forethought, and chargeable as a hate crime, not only as black on white but as cop on citizen. He was smothered in the last nine minutes of his life via positional asphyxiation. None of what he did was deserving of death, but he got it at the hands of the Minneapolis police.
    If these cops walk like the bunch who wailed on Rodney King, expect worse and expect it nationwide. This has been building for a long time. The whole point of the justice system introduced by Hammurabi was to avoid stuff like this. When the cops put themselves beyond the reach of justice, they didn’t get away with anything. They started collectively accruing a terrible debt.

    • Will S.

      August 4, 2020 at 11:55 pm

      Did you watch the video, fuzzy?

      • fuzziewuzziebear

        August 5, 2020 at 12:04 am

        It is irrelevant to what happened later. He was smothered while in handcuffs. They had him in the back of the car, in handcuffs, and lost him. I think that we just got a new definition of police incompetence. Four of them and one of him while in handcuffs and to subdue him, they had to murder him.

      • Will S.

        August 5, 2020 at 12:07 am

        No, it is relevant; he was already yelling “I can’t breathe”, almost as soon as they apprehended him, long before they were restraining him fully.

      • Will S.

        August 5, 2020 at 12:13 am

        IOW, he was lying about not being able to breathe in the first place, long before he literally couldn’t breathe, and no wonder then later he wasn’t believed when he was still saying it.

        Watch the video and read Rod’s synopsis of it.

        You can’t do so and not have questions as to what really went down.

  3. fuzziewuzziebear

    August 4, 2020 at 11:39 pm

    Why did George Floyd die?
    He was murdered by arresting police. Let’s see if we can get a straight answer from them?

    • Will S.

      August 5, 2020 at 12:00 am

      He was killed by them, but was he murdered?

      The technique employed upon him is in the their guidebook, as an allowed technique.

      He wasn’t supposed to die from it.

      But he was high on fentanyl, which changes your heart rate and breathing…

      It’s quite possible the police might get acquitted or a lower charge on the grounds of accidental manslaughter or whatever you call it, rather than murder.

      Will the ghetto thugs and rich brats be justified in further riots, burning down of America’s cities?

      • fuzziewuzziebear

        August 5, 2020 at 12:10 am

        They killed him. It is murder. Anything else is equivocation because they work for government. Don’t allow them to reverse victim order.

        It won’t be inner city people that object exclusively. It will include people that are law abiding objecting to the excesses that police are excused to take. Those are the ones government should be worried about, because they have the right of it and government has been defending the violators.

    • Hun

      August 5, 2020 at 5:06 am

      fuzzie, you are like the a toddler holding ears and screaming. Obviously not interested in facts.

  4. fuzziewuzziebear

    August 5, 2020 at 12:21 am

    Will S.,
    Would you consider this justified? It obvious that the RCMP will get a pass, but it sure looks real bad.

    • Will S.

      August 5, 2020 at 12:25 am

      I don’t think so, no.

      Though for all his trouble, buddy is not only not dead, but not in a coma, walking around, able to be interviewed…

      But every case is different.

      • fuzziewuzziebear

        August 5, 2020 at 12:49 am

        Thank God for small favors, but he easily could have killed him.

      • Will S.

        August 5, 2020 at 12:50 am


  5. fuzziewuzziebear

    August 5, 2020 at 12:43 am

    I think that we have come to the point where we have to prosecute cops when they break the law. We can’t laugh it off anymore because that makes a mockery of justice.

    • Will S.

      August 5, 2020 at 12:47 am

      I agree, if they can be proven to have broken the law, they ought not to have any special privilege granting them immunity from prosecution.

      I know cases where I consider a miscarriage of justice occurred, and it enrages me.

      • fuzziewuzziebear

        August 5, 2020 at 12:55 am

        In the case of Walter Scott, the policeman who emptied a clip into his back got off because of a hung jury. The policeman was convicted of violating his civil rights and will serve twenty one years in federal prison. Sometimes, it takes a while. Then there is the racial issue. I see the victim as retired Coast Guard. Not many people do.

      • Will S.

        August 5, 2020 at 12:59 am

        I think I heard about that at the time.

      • fuzziewuzziebear

        August 5, 2020 at 1:00 am

        “Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for justice, for they shall be satisfied.”
        We can hope.

      • Will S.

        August 5, 2020 at 1:00 am


  6. red

    August 5, 2020 at 10:02 pm

    Why George Floyd had to die. Nazis are socialists. When Hitler took over, all communists but a few ran to jump into the party. A few were chosen and killed to make the claim (a lie) that nazis were anti-communists. When dems needed to prove blacks need to be controlled to stop them from raping white women, one would be picked and prosecuted. No matter if innocent, the news media made certain everyone knew the KKK was watching out for them. A liberal, Floyd lived in a very liberal state, in a very liberal city and was killed by a very liberal cop. Hatye crimes against Trump began because he’s anti-slavery. Where power is concerned, nothing matters but power. dnc/kkk=nazi party usa.

    • Will S.

      August 5, 2020 at 10:15 pm

      Are police all Democrats?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s